“Kill them with kindness”—does that really work?
If you’ve been a nurse for any length of time, you’ve probably been given that advice. The reasoning behind it being, if we lavish extra attention on people who treat us disrespectfully, they might start to like us and stop treating us badly. That approach rarely ever works. In rare cases, it might work for you. But the aggression is usually just redirected towards someone else, like another provider. In that case you become the bully’s ally, simply legitimizing their aggressive behavior towards others.
We wouldn’t advise our kids to be subservient to their bullies, would we? Why not? Though the goal may be to win the bully over, the goals of a bully are simply to dominate, control, and objectify. We instinctively know that bullies cannot be placated by killing them with kindness. Yet it’s often the approach we take in healthcare, usually because we are unsure about what to do. When we are unskilled at setting limits, offering solutions, or making amends when we are truly in the wrong, we are almost assured of negative outcomes.
[cxl url=https://www.cxl1.net/9xFKNTnPVhr width=320 height=180 skin=black]
Instead, we should learn to discriminate between service recovery situations and anti-social or threatening behavior. We also need to be skilled at identifying people in genuine crisis. When people are cursing or yelling at us, or calling us names and otherwise treating us disrespectfully, simply lavishing extra attention on them sends the wrong messages. Messages such as, “It’s okay to treat us that way”, or worse yet, “Disrespecting me gets you what you want.” Perhaps the most dangerous message of all is, “I’m afraid and you can use that to control me.” This is the same sort of cycle that is present in all inter-personal cycles of violence, whether it’s a bullying situation or a domestic violence relationship. And when people are in crisis, we need to offer them privacy and support that is trauma informed and focused on our patients. That is perhaps the kindest thing we can do for them.
-Joel Lashley, author of Vistelar’s new book focused reducing violence and conflict in the healthcare environment. To get your own copy of the book, check it out on Amazon: http://amzn.com/0990910911